Episode 5.12 - Sympathy for the Devil - Spoiler Discussion

by **Leliforever** on Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:39 am

greymaters wrote:CTV promo, very bad quality though
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=bywjdGM7RMc

looks like mama is going to be around throughout the eppi.

Thanks for the promo Donna!!!
I love McMama (even from the promos!)
And Mer was so...helpless when she saw her... :lol:

I wonder if Derek told Mer about McMama's arrival :hmm:

izzie telling Mer to smeli with gestures! :rofl:

by **md_em** on Sat Jan 10, 2009 8:46 pm

greymaters wrote:CTV promo, very bad quality though
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=bywjdGM7RMc

looks like mama is going to be around throughout the eppi.

This CTV promo is quite interesting ... can't wait for next GA :cool:

by **Taylijane** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:16 am

In the CTV promo I cannot make out what Derek is saying in any of his scenes. Other than with Meredith when he is talking about PDR trying to cheat the system and he is not going to let him.

Sunday breakfast BBL!

by **greymaters** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:32 am

Taylijane wrote:In the CTV promo I cannot make out what Derek is saying in any of his scenes. Other than with Meredith when he is talking about PDR trying to cheat the system and he is not going to let him.

Sunday breakfast BBL!

mmmmm sounds good!

when he is talking to his mom, in what looks like a car, maybe..Mom says, "I know your still angry about what happen to dad", and I think Derek says "of course I am, aren't you?"

by **Taylijane** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:43 am

Thanks, Donna. In the second scene with his mother, I think she is trying to tell him it is time to let the "hate" go. I hope he can get some closure to his father's death out of this.

Now the PDR - Jackson transplant thingy. I think Bailey said that the surgery left only 10 cms (4 inches) of bowel. (BTW - he would have to be having IV nutrition by now and he would have an ileostomy at least) It is possible to to have a live donor for liver and intestine (they take only part of the small bowel). However the law says "organs and tissues should be freely given without commercial consideration or financial profit." Would the PDR's situation fit into this or would the law look at the greater good in a special circumstance? There is no commercial or financial profit in this circumstance but he is getting something out of it. And the law says should not must. They must find out that Jackson and PDR are compatible for transplant.

It is an interesting ethical situation. But, it would be the law and the hospital's ethics committee that would finally decide the situation - not Bailey, Derek or the Chief. But this is sr-la-la-land. O.o

by **Leliforever** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:17 am

Well,as I do every week,I'll post here the most importnat parts of the weekly prognosis so we can see what we can "find out" with our spoiler minds! :PP

First of all,I don't know about you but when I saw the promo I was sure that sth was wrong looking at Mer's hair...She never makes her hair like that...and check here ...:

Question 2:
"How will Mer change her hair to impress Derek's mum?"
:lol:

Imagine her face when Derek tells her "Hey,honey,you know...my mum will visit us for a couple of days..." :rofl:

Question 3:
Who will tell Bailey & Robbins to "shut up"
a)Chief b)Derek c)mark d) Alex
(I bet it's Alex because he works with them on the case...or maybe the Chief :hmm:

)

Question 5:
What peronal matter will Derek's mum ask Hunt about?" :hmm:

pretty weird,hah?
a) Christina b)his family c)Meredith d)how he's sleeping
(I thinkk it nay be d...Mcmama looks pretty smart to me so she may ask him how he's sleeping to see if he has any problems...you know post-traumatic... :hmm:

And then he goes to Christina's shower... :hmm:

)

So,what do you girls think???

by **md_em** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:16 pm

Leliforever wrote:Well,as I do every week,I'll post here the most importnat parts of the weekly prognosis so we can see what we can "find out" with our spoiler minds!

First of all,I don't know about you but when I saw the promo I was sure that sth was wrong looking at Mer's hair...She never makes her hair like that...and check here ...:

Question 2:
"How will Mer change her hair to impress Derek's mum?"
Imagine her face when Derek tells her "Hey,honey,you know...my mum will visit us for a couple of days..."

Question 3:
Who will tell Bailey & Robbins to "shut up"
a)Chief b)Derek c)mark d) Alex
(I bet it's Alex because he works with them on the case...or maybe the Chief )

Question 5:
What peronal matter will Derek's mum ask Hunt about?" pretty weird,hah?
a) Christina b)his family c)Meredith d)how he's sleeping
(I thinkk it nay be d...Mcmama looks pretty smart to me so she may ask him how he's sleeping to see if he has any problems...you know post-traumatic... And then he goes to Christina's shower... )

So,what do you girls think???

Hi Leli,
about questions 3 and 5, I would say the same as you, that is Alex and then the sleeping question ...

Anyone thoughts

by **Leliforever** on Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:21 pm

The worst thing is that this mess with Christina &meredith will continue and won'tbe over until next week (episode 5x14) guessing from the pics at Christina's house with derek... :hmm:

I don't like that they're arguing!!!I could not imagine sth like that when Shonda talked about the Christina-Meredith relationship during this season... (before season 5 began) :sleep:

by **McSunny** on Mon Jan 12, 2009 9:29 am

From Pixels at TWOP

CTV had a Derek-centric promo for next week. Most of it had Derek in street clothes.

[Derek's in street clothes and jacket]
- Derek explaining to the SK that his CT scans show that the brain contusions are expanding.
-SK kind of laughing telling him "they're going to execute me in five days."

[Derek in scrubs and lab coat]
-Eating with mom in cafeteria she says "must be awful, treating a murderer."

-Derek in his street clothes walking quickly down the hall

-SK with MerDer. SK is saying as they leave the room "would you fix a broken television before you throw it out?" and Meredith tells Derek that "he [SK] has a point." Derek says he's trying to cheat the system and he's not going to let him do it.

-Mom and Derek in street clothes sitting somewhere. Mom says
"I know how angry you still are about what happened to dad." Derek says "of course I'm angry, aren't you?"

by **Taylijane** on Mon Jan 12, 2009 10:14 am

McSunny wrote:From Pixels at TWOP

CTV had a Derek-centric promo for next week. Most of it had Derek in street clothes.

[Derek's in street clothes and jacket]
- Derek explaining to the SK that his CT scans show that the brain contusions are expanding.
-SK kind of laughing telling him "they're going to execute me in five days."

[Derek in scrubs and lab coat]
-Eating with mom in cafeteria she says "must be awful, treating a murderer."

-Derek in his street clothes walking quickly down the hall

-SK with MerDer. SK is saying as they leave the room "would you fix a broken television before you throw it out?" and Meredith tells Derek that "he [SK] has a point." Derek says he's trying to cheat the system and he's not going to let him do it.

-Mom and Derek in street clothes sitting somewhere. Mom says
"I know how angry you still are about what happened to dad." Derek says "of course I'm angry, aren't you?"

Thanks, Sunny. As I said on the general thread - I sometimes find it hard to "hear" what PD says.

From this and the summary for the next episode - we know the prisoner would prefer to die on the operating table and not be executed. Derek thinks he should be executed even at the risk of Jackson missing out on this chance of a transplant. An interesting ethical dilemma. I wonder which side of the coin the medical profession will come out on this time in sr la-la-land? She usually portrays them as so unethical and unprofessional.

I wonder if she has had a "bad" experience?

by **McSunny** on Tue Jan 13, 2009 10:07 am

Leliforever wrote:Well,as I do every week,I'll post here the most importnat parts of the weekly prognosis so we can see what we can "find out" with our spoiler minds!

First of all,I don't know about you but when I saw the promo I was sure that sth was wrong looking at Mer's hair...She never makes her hair like that...and check here ...:

Question 2:
"How will Mer change her hair to impress Derek's mum?"
Imagine her face when Derek tells her "Hey,honey,you know...my mum will visit us for a couple of days..."

Question 3:
Who will tell Bailey & Robbins to "shut up"
a)Chief b)Derek c)mark d) Alex
(I bet it's Alex because he works with them on the case...or maybe the Chief )

Question 5:
What peronal matter will Derek's mum ask Hunt about?" pretty weird,hah?
a) Christina b)his family c)Meredith d)how he's sleeping
(I thinkk it nay be d...Mcmama looks pretty smart to me so she may ask him how he's sleeping to see if he has any problems...you know post-traumatic... And then he goes to Christina's shower... )

So,what do you girls think???

Hey Leli, I think you nailed it on the answers. Thanks for bringing the questions here. I wish Mer would have left her hair down. Up like that makes her look really young.

by **Leliforever** on Tue Jan 13, 2009 2:54 pm

McSunny wrote:Hey Leli, I think you nailed it on the answers. Thanks for bringing the questions here. I wish Mer would have left her hair down. Up like that makes her look really young.

Hey,always my pleasure...
I agree about Mer's hair...She doesn't only look younger but also much prettier!!!

Any news on Lexie's real life pregnancy?why do I be a feeling that Shonda will go back to her promise and it willbe written on Grey's at the end ... :hmm:

I may send a message to Kristen from E online to ask jher if there is generally going to be sb pregnant (I still cannot forget the general spoilers with the pregnancy .. :hmm: